Purposeful Strategic Partners
Schedule a Call
Articles Client Portal
Business Advising & Financial Planning Establish A 401k Benchmark Your Existing 401(k) Employee Financial Wellness Program Business Coaching
Financial Planning for Families Investment Management Your Retirement Building A Financial Foundation Funding College Ask A CFP - One Hour Session Graduation Gift
Transparency About Josh About Ashley Who We Serve Services & Fees Our Story Our Non-Profit In The News Employment
For Entrepreneurs Business Advising & Financial Planning Establish A 401k Benchmark Your Existing 401(k) Employee Financial Wellness Program Business Coaching For Families Financial Planning for Families Investment Management Your Retirement Building A Financial Foundation Funding College Ask A CFP - One Hour Session Graduation Gift Schedule a Call
Purposeful Strategic Partners
Aligning your finances with your values & purpose
About Transparency About Josh About Ashley Who We Serve Services & Fees Our Story Our Non-Profit In The News Employment ArticlesClient Portal

What should I do with my annuity in its second year if the cap and spread values have been lowered?

I purchased an annuity last year. It just renewed for the second year, and they lowered the cap and the spread values. I didn't even know what they were. I tried to calculate the return for the first year and then for the second year to try and understand how it all works. It appears to me that the annuity company lowered the potential return for the second year. Should I have known what these were before I bought them? I reread the annuity document and saw where these exist and that they can be changed every year. Now, what do I do? Do the insurance companies use these values to cut our returns and enhance theirs, or do I not understand how annuities work?

Ask Purposeful SP A Question
Name *
Thank you!
Joshua is ranked the #1 adviser Nationally by Investopedia’s Advisor Insights audience.*

Joshua Escalante Troesh, CFP

Meet With Josh

I am sad you have to deal with this and it’s unfortunately not uncommon for annuity sales representatives to misrepresent the annuity. As for what to do next, you should determine if it would be better to continue the annuity or give up the money you have already put into it and instead invest using a different strategy. Even though the annuity is a bad investment, there is also likely a penalty you will pay for cancelling the annuity. You may lose all or most of your investment to that penalty.

Explore Options to (Re)invest in an IRA

For many people, canceling the annuity and investing instead in an IRA or other retirement account will provide them with a more considerable retirement benefit than continuing with the annuity. This may not be an option for you, however, considering the annuity is only a year old (cancelling the annuity could have a hefty penalty that needs to be considered in the comparison calculations). At the very least, you should consider whether stopping investing in the annuity and diverting those funds toward an IRA would be in your best interest.

Getting Help with the Calculations

If you don't know how to do these calculations, please feel free to reach out and schedule a meeting. Purposeful Finance, a 501(c)3 nonprofit, also offers a free annuity analysis that helps you understand the difference in expected retirement benefit between an annuity and investing in an IRA, 401(k), or another retirement account. So long as you can find the needed information in the annuity contract, there is no charge. The information usually isn't difficult to find, and from your question, you are likely very capable of understanding the contract enough to find the information.

It’s not your fault

The annuity representative should have explained this to you and made sure you understood what you were buying. The contract/prospectus for annuities is very long and complicated, and I can confidently say many annuity sales representatives (calling themselves "financial advisers") don't fully understand their products.


Joshua Escalante Troesh is a Tenured Professor of Business and works with people across the country as a fiduciary & fee-only financial planner. To explore working with him on your personal financial planning and investment advising needs, simply schedule a no-cost, no-obligation Discover Meeting.


Subscribe to get weekly answers to real people's financial questions.

* indicates required
Retirement Planning, InvestingJoshua Escalante Troesh, CFPJuly 1, 2022Retirement & Legacy, Retirement Planning, Annuities, Annuity, Individual Retirement Account
Facebook0 Twitter Tumblr Pinterest0 0 Likes
Previous

How will today's high inflation impact my retirement?

Retirement Planning, InvestingJoshua Escalante Troesh, CFPAugust 1, 2022Retirement & Legacy, Retirement Planning, Individual Retirement Account, Inflation Risk, 401(k)
Next

How Scary is the National Student Loan Debt?

Debt ManagementJoshua Escalante Troesh, CFPJune 1, 2022Student Loans, Debt Management

Featured In

1 Consumer Report.png
LOGO-Forbes.jpg
usnewsworldreportlogo_Color.jpg
CNBC Image.jpg
 

acorns |

Bloomberg |

Business.com |

CNBC |

Consumer Reports |

Fiduciary News |

Financial Advisor Magazine |

Fit Small Business |

Forbes |

Fundera |

Gulf News |

Hitched |

Huffington Post |

Investopedia |

Lending Tree |

Los Angeles Time |

Self |

Student Loan Hero |

Tampa Bay Times |

The Street |

Wallet Hub |

US News & World Report |

Wall Street Journal |

Wonolo |

Yahoo! News |

acorns | Bloomberg | Business.com | CNBC | Consumer Reports | Fiduciary News | Financial Advisor Magazine | Fit Small Business | Forbes | Fundera | Gulf News | Hitched | Huffington Post | Investopedia | Lending Tree | Los Angeles Time | Self | Student Loan Hero | Tampa Bay Times | The Street | Wallet Hub | US News & World Report | Wall Street Journal | Wonolo | Yahoo! News | acorns | Bloomberg | Business.com | CNBC | Consumer Reports | Fiduciary News | Financial Advisor Magazine | Fit Small Business | Forbes | Fundera | Gulf News | Hitched | Huffington Post | Investopedia | Lending Tree | Los Angeles Time | Self | Student Loan Hero | Tampa Bay Times | The Street | Wallet Hub | US News & World Report | Wall Street Journal | Wonolo | Yahoo! News |

 
Meet With A Financial Planner
Purposeful Strategic Partners
5428 Vinmar Avenue,
Rancho Cucamonga, CA, 91701,
United States
info@purposefulfinance.org
Hours
Mon Open
Tue Open
Wed Open
Thu Open
Fri Open
Sat Open

Purposeful Strategic Partners (Purposeful SP) is a Registered Investment Adviser registered through the SEC with the state of California IARD# 292853

ADA CompliancePrivacy PolicyBlogWhat to Look For in a Financial Adviser
 
Purposeful SP_LOGO-01RGB.png
 
 

*Ranked #1 advisor on Investopedia Advisor Insights November 2018 to July 2019 when Investopedia discontinued Advisor Insights. Investopedia Advisor Insights ranking based upon the helpfulness of answers to questions posted on the Investopedia website as voted by Investopedia’s audience. Ranking does not consider investment returns, client satisfaction, or other factors. Registration as an investment advisor refers to legal licensing of the advisor and does not imply a certain level of skill or training.

Information presented on this website, in our blog, and in the Advisor Answers column is for informational purposes only. None of the information or articles are intended to be investment, tax, nor legal advice. To get personalized advice on your own situation, schedule a meeting with us, talk to your CPA, or contact an attorney. Do not attempt to apply this information to your personal situation without consulting with a qualified adviser.

Joshua Escalante Troesh (“Purposeful Strategic Partners”) is a registered investment adviser offering advisory services in the State of California and in other jurisdictions where exempted.  Registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. The presence of this website on the Internet shall not be directly or indirectly interpreted as a solicitation of investment advisory services to persons of another jurisdiction unless otherwise permitted by statute. Follow-up or individualized responses to consumers in a particular state by Purposeful Strategic Partners in the rendering of personalized investment advice for compensation shall not be made without our first complying with jurisdiction requirements or pursuant an applicable state exemption.

TD Ameritrade and Charles Schwab act as third party custodians for Purposeful Strategic Partners. Client assets are held at either of these institutions for the protection of clients. For individual and family accounts, assets are held at TD Ameritrade or TD Ameritrade. For 401(k) or other employer retirement plan accounts, assets are held at Matrix/Broadridge through a sub-custody relationship with AdvisorTrust.

All written content on this site is for information purposes only. Opinions expressed herein are solely those of Purposeful Strategic Partners, unless otherwise specifically cited.  Material presented is believed to be from reliable sources and no representations are made by our firm as to another parties’ informational accuracy or completeness.  All information or ideas provided should be discussed in detail with an investment advisor, accountant, or legal counsel prior to implementation.